Long Term Incentive Compensation: What It Is & How to Design a Plan That Drives Retention

Introduction

Three years ago, during a consulting project in my previous organisation, I watched a promising engineering lead quit right after a record-breaking product launch. He had no stake in the company, no reason to stick around beyond his salary. 

‍

Despite outperforming peers, he saw no long-term gain. That exit cost the company over $3 million in rehiring and training alone.

‍

This isn’t uncommon. Talented employees crave more than just cash bonuses. They want recognition, trust, and a stake in the future they’re helping to build. That’s where long-term incentive plans (LTIP) step in. It isn’t just about paying people more; it’s about designing incentives that align loyalty, performance, and business goals.

According to the 2024 Pearl Meyer report, 97% of public companies and 68% of private companies grant LTIs to senior executives.  

In this blog, I’ll walk you through what LTIPs really mean, how they differ from short-term plans, why companies use it, and what best-in-class LTIP design looks like today. We’ll also unpack examples, tax considerations, and market trends shaping the future of long-term rewards.

What Is Long-Term Incentive Compensation?

Long-term incentive compensation is a structured reward system that offers equity or cash benefits over multiple years. It motivates employees, aligns individual goals with company strategy, and supports long-term retention. 

Companies use stock options, restricted stock units, and performance shares to link compensation to measurable outcomes. Vesting periods, usually 3–5 years, ensure commitment and continuity. 

These plans are common in executive compensation and high-impact roles. Employers design long-term incentive compensation to attract talent, reduce attrition, and drive sustained performance.

Key Features of Long-Term Incentive Compensation

At its core, long-term incentive compensation is about creating meaningful commitment. It works because it balances risk and reward over time. Employees aren’t just given a bonus, they’re invited into a shared growth model. Vesting conditions ensure that performance or tenure is rewarded only if the long-term value is realized.

Here are the key features that define effective LTIP plans:

• Multi-year vesting (typically 3–5 years): Vesting ensures that employees must remain with the company over time to unlock the full value of their incentive. This encourages commitment and discourages short-term exits.
• Time- or performance-based triggers: LTIP can be awarded based on continued service or the achievement of clear milestones like EBITDA or market share targets. This flexibility helps companies align rewards with strategic objectives.
• Flexible payout mechanisms: Depending on the organization’s structure, LTIP may be delivered as equity (RSUs, stock options), deferred cash, or a hybrid of both. Each format has implications for taxation, dilution, and perceived value.
• Focus on critical roles: LTIP is most effective when offered to employees in roles that drive long-term impact. This often includes executives, senior product leads, engineering managers, or revenue leaders whose decisions influence sustained performance.

By integrating these features, LTIP creates a bridge between employee retention and organizational growth, reinforcing a shared stake in long-term outcomes.

LTIP vs STIP: What's the Difference?

To build a resilient compensation structure, organizations need to understand the distinct roles of short-term and long-term incentives. Both serve different but complementary purposes.

Both STIPs and LTIPs play important roles in a well-rounded compensation strategy. While STIPs motivate execution in the near term, LTIPs reinforce loyalty and drive alignment with company growth. Used together, they form a balanced model that rewards both results and resilience.

Why Companies Use Long-Term Incentive Plans

For any business focused on scaling, innovating, or sustaining a competitive edge, long-term incentive plans serve as more than just compensation tools. They anchor employees, especially key contributors, to the company’s mission and trajectory. 

In 2023, LTIPs made up approximately 70% of total CEO compensation and 60% of CFO compensation, underscoring their significance in executive pay structures

Instead of rewarding isolated wins, LTIPs drive continued engagement by tying employee success to organizational growth.

Key Benefits for Employers

1. Drives alignment with long-term strategy: LTIPs ensure that employee objectives are tightly coupled with the company’s strategic vision. When payouts are conditioned on long-term KPIs, employees are more likely to make decisions that serve the broader business.
2. Reduces executive attrition: One of the most common reasons for leadership churn is a lack of long-term incentives. Equity-based rewards or deferred cash encourage leaders to stay through transformation phases, funding rounds, or exit timelines.
3. Attracts top-tier leadership talent: Senior-level candidates often evaluate compensation packages based on the potential for wealth creation. A well-structured LTIP program can be a compelling differentiator in executive recruitment, especially in startup or high-growth environments.

Key Benefits for Employees

1. Wealth creation through equity: Stock options, RSUs, and performance shares allow employees to grow their financial stake as the company scales. This is particularly appealing in early-stage ventures or high-growth sectors.
2. Long-term job security: The vesting period serves as a built-in career path. Employees are more likely to stay and contribute when future rewards are clearly defined and tied to their tenure or performance.
3. Psychological ownership: LTIP creates a sense of shared accountability. Employees who hold equity or deferred incentives tend to think more like owners, focusing on sustainable outcomes rather than short-term wins.

These benefits explain why organizations across industries, from SaaS firms to manufacturing and healthcare, are increasingly adopting LTIP as a foundational part of their total rewards strategy.

Types of Long-Term Incentive Compensation Plans

Organizations structure their LTIPs based on industry dynamics, maturity, and risk appetite. Each plan type has distinct advantages and trade-offs. Some prioritize equity ownership, others deliver value through cash. Here’s a look at the most common types:

Companies may mix and match plan types based on role criticality, market expectations, and internal equity strategy. For example, tech startups often favor stock options for early employees, while established enterprises might lean toward RSUs or deferred cash for senior executives.

How to Structure a Long-Term Incentive Plan

Creating a successful long-term incentive plan isn’t about copying what competitors do. It’s about aligning your LTIP design with your company’s goals, workforce dynamics, and financial realities. 

A well-structured plan balances business outcomes with talent retention, clarity with flexibility, and financial prudence with competitive appeal.

Step-by-Step Framework

1. Define goals: Start by identifying the primary purpose of your LTIP program. Are you trying to retain senior leadership? Drive innovation? Encourage revenue growth? The goal shapes everything that follows.
2. Identify eligible roles: LTIPs aren’t for everyone. Focus on roles that have a direct impact on long-term business outcomes, typically executives, senior managers, technical leaders, and high-potential talent.
3. Choose LTIP types suited to role and industry: Match the vehicle (e.g., RSUs, stock options, cash deferrals) with your company’s maturity and risk tolerance. Tech companies often lean toward equity-heavy models; traditional industries may favor cash-linked plans.
4. Set performance metrics: Tie rewards to what matters. Common metrics include Total Shareholder Return (TSR), EBITDA growth, Return on Equity (ROE), or strategic milestones like entering a new market. Choose KPIs that are measurable, meaningful, and aligned with shareholder value.
5. Define vesting schedules: Determine how and when rewards vest. This can vary by plan type or recipient tier.
6. Establish payout mechanism: Will the reward be cash, equity, or a blend of both? Consider tax implications, employee preferences, and company liquidity.
7. Model cost vs. impact scenarios: Use compensation modeling tools to simulate different plan designs. Evaluate their financial impact over multiple years before rollout.
8. Communicate the plan effectively: Even the best-designed LTIP fails without clarity. Educate managers and recipients on how the plan works, what triggers payouts, and how it links to their performance.

Vesting Schedules Explained

Vesting determines when employees fully own their LTIP reward. There’s no one-size-fits-all; each model sends a different message about expectations and timelines.

1. Cliff Vesting: The entire reward vests after a set period (e.g., 100% after 3 years). This is simple but binary, employees must stay the full term to benefit.

2. Graded Vesting: The reward vests in tranches over time (e.g., 25% per year for 4 years). This promotes gradual retention and allows partial exits with value.

3. Performance-Based Vesting: Vesting is contingent on hitting specific KPIs. For instance, a product leader might only vest if a new solution meets revenue thresholds within 2 years.

Choosing the Right Performance Metrics

Your metrics should reflect both individual accountability and company strategy. The best LTIP plans balance financial indicators with operational or strategic goals. They must be objective, clearly defined, and tracked consistently over time.

Common options include:

• Total Shareholder Return (TSR): Measures the change in share price and dividends paid, providing a full picture of investor value.‍
• Absolute TSR assesses the company’s total return in isolation, focusing on how much value it has delivered over time.‍
• Relative TSR compares the company’s performance against a peer group or index, ensuring payouts reflect market context and not just broader economic tailwinds.

Relative TSR is often favoured by boards and investors for its objectivity and external benchmarking.

• Return on Equity (ROE): Helps assess how effectively management is using equity investments to generate profits.
• EBITDA growth: Highlights improvements in core business efficiency before taxes or financing distort the picture.
• Earnings per Share (EPS): Indicates profitability per unit of ownership and is a key figure for public companies.
• Market expansion or innovation milestones: Especially relevant in high-growth sectors where traditional financial KPIs may lag behind operational success.

The choice of metric should also reflect the maturity of the organization. For example, early-stage companies might reward product delivery milestones or user growth, while established firms may focus on EPS or ROE.

Ultimately, selecting the right metrics ensures LTIPs are credible, measurable, and aligned with what the business is trying to achieve. 

Who Should Get Long-Term Incentives?

Not every employee in an organization needs a long-term incentive. LTIP works best when targeted at roles where continuity, high-impact performance, and strategic alignment are most critical. 

These roles influence the company’s trajectory, drive innovation, or manage complex teams and revenue centers.

Typical Recipients

1. C-level executives: These leaders shape long-term strategy and directly impact shareholder value. Their decisions often carry multi-year consequences, making LTIP essential for aligning their interests with the company’s growth.

2. VPs and senior directors: Individuals at this level often own large portfolios or lead cross-functional initiatives. LTIP helps ensure stability and long-term thinking in roles critical to execution and delivery.

3. Top performers and R&D leaders: High-impact talent in product, engineering, and innovation roles frequently drive outcomes that unfold over years. LTIP can serve both as a reward and a retention mechanism in these cases.

Expanding Access to LTIP

As organizations scale, they often broaden LTIP eligibility beyond the executive tier to create stronger alignment across the org chart.

1. Mid-level managers in fast-growth firms: These employees are often responsible for scaling teams, processes, or infrastructure. Their contribution becomes increasingly strategic as the company matures.

2. Retention-critical talent in high-churn functions: In industries like tech or BPO, where attrition rates are high, extending LTIP to critical roles, such as top-performing account managers or system architects, can reduce costly turnover and stabilize performance.

Expanding access to LTIP not only boosts retention but also strengthens the sense of ownership across broader swaths of the organization. When employees feel invested in long-term success, they tend to think beyond quarterly goals and act with greater accountability.

Managing and Tracking Long-Term Incentive Compensation Plans

Designing an LTIP plan is only the first step. Administering it effectively is where many companies struggle. Without a clear operational framework and reliable tools, even well-designed plans can fall apart due to poor visibility, compliance risk, or employee confusion.

1. Centralized Equity Management Platforms

Administering equity across departments, geographies, and plan types requires a secure, centralized platform. These platforms help companies manage long-term incentive data at scale, ensuring real-time access, audit readiness, version control, and consistency across HR, finance, legal, and executive teams.

2. Real-Time Dashboards for Tracking

Transparency builds trust. Real-time dashboards help HR, finance, and participants monitor vesting timelines, performance milestones, and eligibility status. This reduces the risk of miscommunication and minimizes dependency on static spreadsheets.

3. Automated Compliance and Tax Handling

As plans scale globally, compliance becomes more complex. Automation simplifies tax calculations, regulatory filings, and local compliance, helping teams stay aligned with regional rules and deadlines.

4. HR and Finance Enablement

LTIP execution depends on cross-functional understanding. Internal teams must be trained to communicate plan mechanics, answer participant questions, and enforce governance with clarity and confidence.

5. Compensation Planning and Forecasting 

Strategic forecasting enables companies to anticipate costs, simulate payout scenarios, and assess financial exposure. This visibility ensures LTIP remains sustainable and aligned with long-term budgets.

6. Ongoing Plan Evaluation and Optimization

No LTIP plan should remain static. Regular evaluations of performance data, employee sentiment, and cost impact help refine plan design. Periodic adjustments ensure relevance as company goals evolve.

With the right tools and processes in place, companies can move beyond manual administration and build an LTIP that is scalable, compliant, and value-driven.

Examples of Effective Long-Term Incentive Plans

Across industries, leading companies have customized their LTIP strategies to suit their business models, growth stages, and employee profiles. Here are a few proven approaches:

1. Tech: Stock Options to Reward Startup Growth

In early-stage tech companies, stock options are widely used to attract and retain high-potential talent when cash compensation is limited. These options give employees the right to buy company shares at a fixed price, aligning their financial upside with the startup’s valuation growth.

There are two main types: Incentive Stock Options (ISOs) and Non-Qualified Stock Options (NSOs).

ISOs offer favourable tax treatment but are subject to strict eligibility and holding requirements. NSOs, on the other hand, are more flexible but are taxed as ordinary income at exercise. As the company matures, stock options can generate significant wealth for early team members and drive long-term retention through multi-year vesting schedules.

2. Healthcare: Performance Shares Tied to Clinical and R&D KPIs

In the healthcare and life sciences sector, LTIP plans often center around performance shares that are triggered by milestones like FDA approval, clinical trial success, or R&D breakthroughs. This ensures that incentive payouts align with high-stakes business objectives and regulatory timelines. 

Such structures are especially valuable in aligning researchers, medical directors, and innovation leaders with long-term business outcomes.

3. Manufacturing: Deferred Cash Bonuses for Operational Longevity

In capital-intensive industries like manufacturing, equity plans may not always be suitable. Instead, companies use deferred cash bonuses tied to long-term metrics such as plant efficiency, safety records, or cost savings initiatives. 

These plans reward continuity and encourage operational leadership to drive sustainable improvements across multi-year periods.

4. Private Firms: Phantom Equity for Senior Contributors

Private, often family-run firms tend to avoid issuing real equity due to ownership concerns. Phantom equity plans are a practical alternative, employees receive bonuses tied to the company’s valuation growth without holding actual shares. 

These plans are particularly effective for rewarding senior leaders or key contributors while maintaining control and avoiding dilution.

Challenges & Compliance Considerations in LTIPs

Even well-intentioned LTIPs can go off track without careful planning and governance. Here are the most common challenges that companies encounter:

Common Pitfalls

1. Overly complex plan design: When plans are difficult to understand, they lose their motivational impact. Employees are unlikely to value what they cannot interpret or track.
2. Poor communication = underutilization: Failure to explain plan mechanics, eligibility, and benefits often leads to disengagement. Many recipients may not realize the value of their incentives until it’s too late, or never.
3. Misaligned KPIs = gaming the system: Tying rewards to the wrong metrics can lead to behavior that optimizes for payouts, not actual performance. For example, rewarding revenue growth without profit accountability can drive poor financial decisions.

Regulatory & Tax Considerations

1. IRC Section 409A (U.S. non-qualified plans): In the U.S., Section 409A applies to all nonqualified deferred compensation arrangements, including certain equity grants, bonus deferrals, and severance agreements. It governs the timing of deferral elections and distributions. Non-compliance can result in immediate income inclusion, a 20% additional tax, and interest penalties for affected employees.
2. ESOP and equity compliance (India, UK, EU): Regional differences in employee equity regulation are significant. In India, ESOPs must comply with the Companies Act and SEBI (SBEBSE) guidelines. In the UK and EU, tax treatment, reporting obligations, and plan approval processes vary by jurisdiction and plan type, whether it's EMI options, RSUs, or growth shares.
3. Withholding and payout taxation: Regardless of whether payouts are in cash or equity, companies must handle tax withholding, reporting, and compliance across jurisdictions. The taxation point, grant, vesting, or exercise can vary by country and plan type, directly influencing employee outcomes and satisfaction.

Navigating these regulatory dimensions requires ongoing legal and tax consultation, especially for global firms. A proactive compliance strategy not only protects the company but also boosts employee trust and clarity.

Best Practices for Long-Term Incentive Plans

Getting LTIP right is not a one-time exercise. It requires continual fine-tuning, clear communication, and benchmarking against evolving market practices. 

Here are the best practices that high-performing organizations follow:

1. Benchmark regularly with Mercer, WorldatWork, and Radford: These firms provide valuable market data that helps ensure your LTIP structure remains competitive within your industry and region.

2. Tailor LTIP type to business stage: A startup may benefit from stock options or hybrid RSU plans, while a public company might rely on performance shares or deferred cash bonuses. One size does not fit all.

3. Reassess KPIs annually: Business priorities shift, and so should your performance metrics. Annual reviews prevent misalignment and ensure incentives are tied to the current strategy.

4. Use transparent dashboards and earnings calculators: Visual tools help employees understand how their incentives work and when they vest. Transparency increases trust and perceived value.

5. Train managers to explain plans simply: Mid-level and senior managers are often the bridge between HR and employees. Equip them with the knowledge and language to explain LTIP clearly, avoiding confusion and disengagement.

Following these practices doesn’t just improve plan performance, it builds a culture of clarity, fairness, and long-term commitment.

Market Trends Impacting LTIPs

Long-term incentive plans are evolving in response to changing employee expectations, economic shifts, and broader ESG mandates. Organizations are adjusting plan structures and performance metrics to stay relevant, competitive, and aligned with stakeholder interests.

1. Rising Popularity of RSUs in Tech

RSUs are gaining favor in tech companies due to their simplicity and guaranteed value at vesting. Unlike stock options, RSUs are less volatile and more predictable, which appeals to employees in uncertain economic climates or at later-stage startups heading toward IPO.

In 2023, 86% of companies granted multiple LTIP vehicles, upholding trends observed since 2019, including the rising use of RSUs and hybrid plans. 

2. Hybrid Cash + Equity in High-Inflation Markets

In inflationary environments, companies are combining equity with deferred cash bonuses to preserve perceived value while managing liquidity. This mix allows organizations to hedge against equity market volatility while still promoting long-term engagement.

3. Shift to Broad-Based Equity in Growth Companies

More high-growth firms are expanding LTIP eligibility beyond executives to include managers and key contributors. Broad-based equity plans help build a sense of shared ownership and reduce attrition during scale-up phases.

4. Sustainability Metrics in Performance Shares (ESG-linked goals)

As ESG expectations rise, companies are incorporating sustainability goals into LTIP structures. Performance shares tied to emissions reduction, diversity targets, or ESG ratings are becoming more common, especially in sectors with regulatory exposure or investor scrutiny.

5. Broader Economic Trends Impacting LTIPs

Macroeconomic factors such as market volatility, interest rate shifts, and geopolitical risks are prompting companies to stress-test their LTIP models. Organizations are reassessing assumptions around stock price growth, exit timelines, and liquidity events to ensure plans remain viable.

6. Shifts in Employee Attitudes and Expectations 

Today’s workforce expects transparency, flexibility, and values-based rewards. Younger employees often prioritize equity over bonuses, but they also want to see tangible long-term value. LTIPs are evolving to reflect these preferences through shorter vesting periods, clearer communication, and more inclusive access.

These trends indicate a growing need for adaptability in LTIP strategy. Companies that respond quickly to market signals and employee sentiment are more likely to retain top talent and sustain alignment through economic cycles.

Conclusion

Long-term incentive compensation has become a foundational component of modern total rewards strategy. It’s no longer limited to senior executives or tech startups; organizations across industries now rely on LTIP to drive retention, align talent with business goals, and support performance over multi-year horizons.

Yet as plans become more widespread, they also become more complex. Execution matters just as much as design. To succeed, companies need tools that bring clarity to participants, efficiency to HR teams, and compliance at scale.

Everstage helps companies streamline LTIP administration, improve visibility for participants, and stay compliant across markets, turning complex incentive programs into simple, motivating experiences.

If you're looking to upgrade how you manage long-term incentive plans, it’s time to explore what Everstage can do for your team.

‍